The 5 Must-Try Slices At Nick's Pizza South Beach: A 2025 Guide To Miami's Most Famous Slice Shop

Nick's Pizza South Beach remains one of the most talked-about and essential stops in the vibrant Miami Beach dining scene. As of December 11, 2025, this iconic slice shop at 100 Collins Avenue is still delivering massive, authentic New York-style pizza slices and full pies to locals, tourists, and late-night revelers alike. Known for its no-frills attitude and high-quality ingredients, Nick's has solidified its reputation as the go-to spot for a true taste of the Northeast in the heart of the Florida tropics. The combination of its prime location and its commitment to classic, oversized slices makes it a culinary landmark that continues to thrive against the backdrop of South Beach's ever-changing restaurant landscape.

The establishment is a testament to the enduring appeal of simple, well-executed food, proving that sometimes, all you need is a giant, perfectly charred slice of pizza to satisfy the most demanding cravings. Whether you are coming straight from the sands of South Beach or winding down after a night out, Nick's Pizza offers a consistent, delicious, and surprisingly diverse menu that caters to every palate, including a robust selection of specialty and vegan options that keep the menu fresh and relevant.

Nick's Pizza South Beach: The Concept Profile and Location

While the specific biography of the founder remains private, the "Nick's Pizza" concept at 100 Collins Avenue, Miami Beach, is a clear homage to the classic, no-nonsense New York slice joint. It is a brand built on the promise of authenticity and sheer size, distinguishing itself from the myriad of upscale and trendy eateries in the Art Deco District. The location is strategically placed on Collins Avenue, making it easily accessible and a popular late-night fixture for those enjoying the Miami nightlife.

• The Unseen Story Jessica Simpsons Battle For Privacy And Body Image In A Digital Age Mlvqa

The pizzeria's core identity revolves around its massive, authentic New York-style pies, which are sold by the slice or as a whole. This focus on traditional quality, coupled with a willingness to embrace modern culinary trends like hot honey and high-quality vegan alternatives, gives Nick's a unique topical authority in the competitive South Beach food market. The phone number for direct inquiries and orders is (786) 864-2160, and its address is 100 Collins Avenue, Unit CU4, Miami Beach, FL 33139. The shop is often found next to other local businesses, like OAKBERRY Açaí, cementing its presence in a high-traffic retail block.

Key Operational and Identity Entities:

• Location: 100 Collins Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33139.
• Cuisine Style: Authentic New York-style Pizza.
• Signature Offering: Oversized Pizza Slices (often referred to as 2-foot slices).
• Customer Experience: Quick, casual, and friendly service, perfect for takeout or a quick bite.
• Controversy Note: Despite a few outdated "CLOSED" listings online, the active presence on major delivery platforms (Grubhub, DoorDash, Uber Eats) and recent customer reviews confirm it is currently operational and serving customers.

The 5 Essential Slices and Pies You Must Try

Nick's Pizza doesn't just serve a basic cheese slice; their menu is a curated list of high-impact flavors designed to leave a lasting impression. From the spicy-sweet to the intensely savory, these are the five menu items that have cemented Nick's reputation as the best pizza in Miami Beach.

1. The Swine Killer Triple Pepperoni

This is arguably the most famous pie on the menu and a must-try for meat lovers. The Swine Killer Triple Pepperoni is a decadent layering of three distinct types of pepperoni, creating a complex, savory, and slightly spicy profile. The abundance of meat ensures every bite has that signature "cup and char" effect, making it a textural masterpiece. It's a bold choice that perfectly embodies the indulgent spirit of South Beach dining.

• Shania Twains Bold Statement Why The Star Chose Nude Photoshoots At 57 Qf9cg

2. Nick's Fav: Hot Honey, Pepperoni, and Straciatella

The Nick's Fav is the perfect example of the pizzeria's willingness to blend classic comfort with modern, gourmet flair. This pie features a classic pepperoni base elevated by a generous drizzle of Hot Honey and dollops of creamy Straciatella cheese. The combination of the sweet heat from the honey and the cool, fresh richness of the Straciatella provides a flavor contrast that is both addictive and highly memorable. This specialty pie has become a social media favorite.

3. The Classic NY Cheese Pizza

You can't judge a slice shop without trying its foundation. The Family Size NY Cheese Pizza is the gold standard here. It features a thin, foldable crust with a perfectly crisp edge, high-quality mozzarella, and a robust, slightly sweet tomato sauce. This classic option is what proves their mastery of the New York-style technique and is often cited by purists as the best traditional slice in the area.

4. The Vegan Pepperoni Pizza

In a nod to Miami's diverse and health-conscious population, Nick's offers excellent vegan options, with the Vegan Pepperoni Pizza leading the charge. This pie is praised for its quality plant-based cheese and "pepperoni" that delivers a convincing, savory bite without any animal products. The kitchen staff is known for being careful, sometimes even using a dedicated, clean pizza cutter to avoid cross-contamination for those with strict dietary needs.

• The Untouchable Privacy 7 Secrets Of Rachel Mcadams And Jamie Lindens Life Beyond The Red Carpet E820e

5. The Oversized Slices (The Big Slice Challenge)

While not a specific topping, ordering a single Oversized Slice is an essential Nick's experience. These slices are famously huge—often described as being two feet long—and are the centerpiece of the viral "Size Matters' Big Slice Pizza Challenge." Competitive eaters, including YouTube personality James Webb ("J WEBBY CAN EAT"), have visited the 100 Collins Ave location to take on this massive culinary feat, adding to the shop's fame and drawing in curious customers.

Beyond the Pizza: Unexpected Menu Entities

While pizza is the main attraction, Nick's topical authority extends to a few surprising, high-quality side items that are worth exploring. These unique offerings help round out the menu and provide alternatives for those looking for something different after a long day at the beach.

The Famous Lobster Rolls

One of the most unexpected, yet highly praised, menu items is the Lobster Roll. Customers rave about the top-quality ingredients and the incredible flavor of these rolls, which are a surprising but welcome addition to a pizzeria menu. This item showcases the kitchen's ability to execute high-end, fresh seafood alongside their casual, cheesy staples.

The Nashville Hot Vegan Chicken Sandwich

Further demonstrating their commitment to diverse and trendy options, the Nashville Hot Vegan Chicken Sandwich is a standout. This spicy, plant-based sandwich appeals to the growing demand for flavorful vegan comfort food, providing a substantial, satisfying alternative to pizza. It’s a perfect example of how Nick's Pizza South Beach maintains a fresh and current menu in 2025.

Garlic Knots

No true New York-style pizzeria is complete without perfect Garlic Knots. Nick's version is a simple, classic side—pillowy soft, drenched in garlic butter, and served with marinara sauce for dipping. They are a great, affordable companion to the massive slices and a reliable crowd-pleaser.

Whether you are a local seeking a reliable, high-quality meal or a tourist exploring the best of the South Beach dining scene, Nick's Pizza at 100 Collins Avenue provides an unforgettable, authentic experience. Its commitment to the oversized slice, combined with a surprisingly diverse and modern menu featuring everything from the Swine Killer to fantastic vegan options, ensures its continued status as a Miami Beach institution. Stop by for a slice—you won't need two.