The REAL Reason Paige DeSorbo And Craig Conover Broke Up: A Timeline Of Conflicting Narratives And New Romances

The question of "Did Paige and Craig break up?" has been definitively answered, but the full story is far more complex than a simple split announcement. As of December 10, 2025, the Bravo power couple, Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover, have officially ended their three-year relationship, a bombshell revelation that has since been followed by conflicting narratives, emotional fallout, and surprisingly quick new romances for both reality stars. This deep dive uncovers the real reasons behind the split and details how both stars have fully moved on in the post-breakup landscape of 2025. The stunning news first surfaced in late December 2024, when the *Summer House* star confirmed the split on her popular *Giggly Squad* podcast. While Paige initially characterized the separation as a mutual decision, her *Southern Charm* ex-boyfriend quickly countered her statement, claiming he was completely "blindsided" by the news. The public unraveling of their relationship has become a central storyline across the Bravo universe, offering a rare, raw look at the end of a high-profile reality TV romance.

The Full Profile: Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover

To understand the high-stakes nature of their split, it’s essential to look at the careers and backgrounds of the two reality TV giants who met and fell in love on the first season of *Winter House*.

Paige DeSorbo: Biography & Career

• Full Name: Paige Audi DeSorbo
• Date of Birth: November 4, 1992
• Age: 33 (as of late 2025)
• Hometown: Loudonville, New York
• Education: Saint Rose in Albany, New York
• Career: Television Personality, Podcaster, Fashion Influencer, Freelance TV Host, and Journalist.
• Known For: Main cast member on Bravo's *Summer House* (since Season 3), co-host of the *Giggly Squad* podcast with Hannah Berner. She is known for her sharp wit and elevated sense of fashion.
• Key Entities: *Summer House*, *Giggly Squad*, Hannah Berner, fashion journalism.

Craig Conover: Biography & Career

• Full Name: Craig Conover
• Date of Birth: February 9, 1989
• Age: 36 (as of late 2025)
• Hometown: Fenwick Island, Delaware
• Education: College of Charleston, Charleston School of Law (Juris Doctor)
• Career: Television Personality, Attorney (currently inactive), Businessman, Author.
• Known For: Main cast member on Bravo's *Southern Charm* (since Season 1). Founder and owner of the successful home goods company, Sewing Down South.
• Key Entities: *Southern Charm*, Sewing Down South, Austen Kroll, Shep Rose, Charleston School of Law, *Pillow Talk: What's Wrong with My Sewing?* (his book).

The Conflicting Breakup Timeline: Mutual Split vs. Blindsided Call

The most compelling and dramatic element of the split is the starkly different accounts of how the three-year relationship actually ended. The initial announcement by Paige was quickly complicated by Craig’s emotional response, setting the stage for a public debate over who initiated the final separation.

Paige's Narrative: The Mutual & Necessary Split

• The Surprise Vegas Wedding And Shared Grief 5 Shocking Details Of John Schneider And Dee Dee Sorvinos Whirlwind Romance Ohirf

Paige DeSorbo first broke the news on her podcast, stating, "Craig and I have decided to no longer be together." She elaborated that the decision was based on a realization that they wanted fundamentally different things in life. The final straw, according to her later comments, occurred around Thanksgiving weekend 2024.

During the *Summer House* season finale, she opened up further, explaining that she realized she couldn't picture spending future holidays with him, which was a clear sign that he wasn't "the one." This was a major point of contention, as the couple had long struggled to reconcile their lives in New York City (Paige's home) and Charleston, South Carolina (Craig's base), a classic "bicoastal relationship" struggle that ultimately proved too difficult to overcome.

Craig's Narrative: The Blindsided Phone Call

• The One Where They Tanked Jokes 15 Shocking New Secrets From The Friends Tv Show Behind The Scenes G9zdh

Craig Conover's reaction was one of shock and hurt. He later addressed the situation on *Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen* (*WWHL*), claiming Paige's 'mutual split' announcement was a lie. Craig revealed he was "blindsided" and that Paige had called him "out of the blue" to deliver the news, suggesting the decision was entirely hers.

He expressed that the timing was unexpected, coming shortly after they had filmed together. Craig also emotionally reflected on the relationship, hinting at deeper issues, including struggles with their "sex life" that he felt were not fully addressed. His public response painted a picture of a man who was ready for the next step, possibly marriage and a family, but whose partner was not on the same page, leading to an "unexpected" end.

The Real Reasons: Distance, Future Plans, and Lifestyle Differences

Beyond the he-said/she-said drama, reality TV observers and sources close to the couple have pointed to several core issues that led to the relationship's demise. These lifestyle and future goal discrepancies are common themes in long-distance relationships.

• The Enduring Legacy Of Haylor 5 Shocking Facts About Harry Styles And Taylor Swifts Relationship 10 Years Later Sf662

1. The NYC vs. Charleston Divide

The geographical distance between Paige's life in New York and Craig's life in Charleston, South Carolina, was a constant source of tension. Paige was reluctant to leave her career and friends in New York, while Craig was deeply rooted in Charleston with his business, Sewing Down South, and his castmates from *Southern Charm*. The inability to commit to a shared city for the long term made planning a future together virtually impossible.

2. Marriage and Family Timelines

Craig, who is three years older and often spoke about wanting to settle down, was clearly ready for marriage and children, a sentiment often captured on *Southern Charm*. Paige, however, was repeatedly vocal about not feeling ready to take those next steps, particularly on her own show, *Summer House*. This misalignment in their long-term visions—Craig pushing for commitment and Paige prioritizing her independence and career—created an irreconcilable gap.

3. Speculation on Lifestyle and Drinking

While not explicitly confirmed by Paige, fan discussion and speculation across social media platforms heavily suggested that Craig's lifestyle and issues with alcohol, which have been documented on *Southern Charm*, may have played a role. The pressure of maintaining sobriety while filming a party-centric show like *Summer House* or managing the social scene in Charleston likely added significant strain to the relationship, especially for a partner who was looking for stability.

Moving On: Craig and Paige's New Romances in 2025

In a twist that shocked many fans who expected a longer period of mourning, both Paige and Craig have swiftly moved into new relationships, demonstrating their readiness to put the past behind them and focus on their respective futures in 2025.

Paige DeSorbo and Joe D'Amelio

By mid-2025, Paige was reportedly dating Joe D'Amelio, a prominent figure in the sports and entertainment world. Joe D'Amelio is known as a Senior Vice President at Klutch Sports, a major agency representing top athletes. The relationship quickly gained traction, with the couple spotted on romantic trips, including a high-profile outing in Capri, Italy, confirming that Paige had officially moved on from the Bravo bubble and into a new chapter with a successful executive.

Craig Conover and Natalie Buffett

Craig Conover also confirmed that he was "seeing someone new" just months after the split was announced, indicating he was actively dating again. Sources identified his new girlfriend as Natalie Buffett, an influencer with ties to the sports world, who was previously linked to a high-profile NFL star. Craig confirmed on *WWHL* that he was in a new relationship, suggesting he found the emotional support and connection he needed to move past the breakup and focus on his future.

The speed at which both reality stars found new partners is a testament to the fast-paced nature of their lives, but it also solidifies that the "Paige and Craig break up" is a closed chapter. While their dramatic relationship and subsequent split will be a topic of discussion on Bravo shows for seasons to come, both Paige and Craig appear to be focused on their new romances and their individual careers, leaving the bicoastal drama firmly in the past.